Clear thinking and strong voices needed


Opportunity lost? Avanti West Coast’s‘climate train’Pendolino No 390121 passes Rugeley North Junction on 11 July 2022. The cancellation of Phase 2a means HS2 trains bound for the North West and Scotland will jostle for space on the Trent Valley line and other busy stretches with existing services.
John Whitehouse

As the storm about HS2 rumbled on, leading to the eventual cancellation of the northern legs by the Prime Minister, the railway had top billing in the news headlines. This in itself might seem remarkable, given the many other stories vying for attention.

When it came, Rishi Sunak’s decision was not a surprise, rehearsed as it was during the constant speculation in the days before. What we didn’t know was how the potential borrowing for HS2 would be redirected. It seems Mr Sunak wanted a list of other investments he could excitedly call out at great speed to win applause in his party conference speech – but once the speech was over and the Government’s ‘Network North’ document was published, things soon began to unravel.

What was sold by the Prime Minister as a series of investment commitments in fact turned out to be at best a wishlist of schemes for illustrative purposes, many of which do not have business cases prepared and for which funding must be obtained separately. Bear in mind that funds borrowed for HS2 could only be used for that, not for other schemes. Of course, there are some very worthy schemes in there, dotted across the country, some of which are fairly well developed, but it soon emerged that the likelihood of them all being delivered is slim.

Want to read more?

This is a premium article and requires an active subscription.

Existing subscriber? Sign in now

I have a subscription but need to register on site…

You will need your print Customer ID ready to set up an account, you'll find this on your welcome email and cover sheet delivered with each print magazine.

Register now

No subscription?

Pick one of our introductory offers