Alan Williams: Our pundit in the North

When the virus struck and rail ridership fell through the floor, the train operating companies (TOCs) gratefully fell into the arms of the men from the Ministry and most of us thought that was right. And as the Prime Minister had told everybody to stay at home, it probably was.

But as lockdown progressed, the TOCs seemed to go over the top into self-destruct mode. Whereas the Department for Transport website merely asked ‘Consider all other forms of transport, such as cycling and walking, before using public transport’, the messages from TOCs became increasingly draconian, with various versions of ‘do not travel by train’. Southern was saying ‘only travel by train if it is really necessary.’ Greater Anglia simply said ‘avoid public transport’.

West Midlands Railway went further. Under a heading reminiscent of World War 2, it demanded ‘Is your journey necessary?’ and ‘Can you travel another way?’ Before you could even see which services were available, the website required that you tick four boxes which included ‘my travel is necessary because I am a key worker, or a worker not able to work from home’. Even the National Rail website began with ‘if you have to travel…’, implying they would really prefer you didn’t.

Want to read more?

This is a premium article and requires an active subscription.

Existing subscriber? Sign in now

I have a subscription but need to register on site…

You will need your print Customer ID ready to set up an account, you'll find this on your welcome email and cover sheet delivered with each print magazine.

Register now

No subscription?

Pick one of our introductory offers